Stupid Is As Stupid Does Stacie Somers

itunes.jpg

When you have the most popular digital music player on the planet, the largest digital music store, and billions of cash on hand, you tend to attract outsiders who want a piece of the action. Apple, meet Stacie Somers.

On December 31st, 2007, Stacie Somers filed a class action lawsuit against Apple for violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act among other things. You can view the entire 24 page filing here. So what nuggets of information can we find within?

Page 2 # 6: “Online Video make it superior to DVDs purchased from traditional retail outlets.”

If you think video hobbled with DRM, a lower picture quality than DVD, and no special features makes it “superior”, the I’ve got some great beach property in Kansas to sell you Stacie.

Page 4 # 13: “Apple has repeatedly acted to foreclose even the possibility ofcompetition by using its market power to force consumers to choose its products based not on their merits, but on the fact that technological restrictions and incompatibilities prevent them from buying its competitors’ products.”

So you’re saying that it’s not because the iPod looks amazing, easily works with the music management software (iTunes), or is so very easy to use? What you’re saying is that when you go to pay for your Zune the credit card machine breaks down because Apple remotely disabled the connection to the credit card processor? Makes perfect sense to me.

Continue reading

WSJ Has A Good Article On The Think Secret Shut Down

thinksecretlogo3.png

The Wall Street Journal has a good article on the shutting down of the Apple rumor and news website Think Secret. Though not confirmed by Think Secret owner Nick Ciarelli, Kurt Opsahl from the Electronic Frontier Foundation said, “it would be surprising if Apple did not include a payment as part of the settlement, given the bargaining position”.

On December 20th, 2007 Think Secret announced a settlement to the lawsuit Apple brought against Nick Ciarelli in 2005. At issue was the identity of the source used in the Think Secret prediction of a low cost Mac without a monitor (Mac Mini). Mr. Ciarelli refused to give up his source in the wake of the lawsuit. In the confidential settlement announcement, it states that he never gave up his source.

If you have a WSJ account, the WSJ article is here. If you don’t have a WSJ account, you can view the article via Google Finance. Visit the AAPL page in Google Finance here. On the right side of the graph look for the article titled ” Apple Fan Site to Shut Down To Settle Lawsuit by Apple” with a December 20th date (also noted by the “E” on the graph).